BBC: Keeping kids off smartphones

Can I ask you something, Beth...? Beth? Hello, Beth? Are you listening?

Oh, sorry, Neil! I was er...checking my Instagram, and ugh... Facebook...and, just sending this email...done! Now, what did you wnat?

Well, I wanted to ask if you're getting addicted to your smartphone, but clearly the answer is 'yes'!

Actually, Neil, I am worried about my smartphone use, and it's not just me. Concerns are growing about the negative effect smartphones are having on adults and, even more, on children.

Studies show that girls who spend more time on social media are more likely to be anxious or depressed, and smartphones have also been linked to delayed brain development and poor sleep. 

Even so, around 60% of British eight-to-eleven-year-olds have a smartphone. So, in this programme, we'll be asking: are kids better off without a phone? And, of course, we'll be learning some useful new vocabulary too. 

But first, put your phone away, Beth, because I have a question for you. The US has one of the highest levels of smartphone use, but according to a recent survey, how long does the average American 11-to-14-year-old spend looking at a screen every day? Is it: 

a) fiven hours   b) seven hours   or   c) nine hours?

I'll guess American teens spend live hours a day on screens. 

OK, Beth, I'll reveal the answer later in the programme. BBC journalist, Myra Anubi, has a nine-year-old daughter who desperately wants her own phone. But Myra isn't convinced, as she explained to BBC World Service programme, 'People Fixing the world':

I'm worried about how much time she'll spend on her own device and what she might even see there. I mean, she's only nine at the end of the day. But at the same time, I don't want her to feel left out because some of her friends already have smartphones, and there's a chance that she'll miss out on play dates or kids' trends, cat videos or online chats with her besties. So, I'm torn between wanting her to be in our world, and also letting her be in her own mini world with her friends. 

Myra's daughter wants to chat with her besties- her best friends. But Myra worries she'll get hooked on social media, see harmful content, or spend too long online. Myra is torn between letting her daughter get a phone and not, if you're torn between two things, you can't decide between two possibilities, leaving you feeling anxious. 

Parents like Myra are having to make an impossible choice- either give their children potentially harmful devices, or risk alienating them from their friends who do have smartphones. 

In February 2024, mums Daisy Greenwell and Clare Femyhough, started a WhatsApp group encouraged parents to not give their child a smartphone until the age of 14, with no social medial access until 16. Soon, the phone-free group of families grew into a movement, 'Smartphone Free Childhood'. Here, mum, Daisy Greenwell, explains more to BBC World Service's, 'People Fixing the World':

Everyone I spoke to said, 'Yes, it's a nightmare getting your child a phone, but you've got no choice. You have to because everyone else is doing it. You can't leave them on their own. So, Clare and I decided to start a WhatsApp group to support each other, and I posted about it on social media, and it went viral. The group is full so we encourage people, start one in your region, in your county, and they sprung up all over the country right in front of our eyes. It was amazing! And now there's over 100,000 people in the UK who are in our community. 

At the start, Daisy says it was a nightmare- a very unpleasant situation. Everyone else's kids had a phone, and Daisy didn't want her children to feel left our. But soon, more families got inovlved, and the group went viral, it spread quickly and widely on the internet and social medial. 

Within months, new groups started up across Britanin, right in front of Daisy's eyes. If you say something happens right in front of your eyes, you are emphasising that something surprising or unusual happened directly before you.